Excellence in Teaching Award Criteria

2027 Excellence in Teaching Award: Evaluation Criteria

  • Nomination Form with a signature of endorsement from the Dean of the Graduate
    School/College
  • Letter of support from the nominating department head/chair, not to exceed two
    pages (includes description of any departmental and institutional honors awarded
    to this masters/doctoral student for excellence in teaching)
  • Nominee’s Teaching Portfolio (maximum of 6 pages double spaced; 12-point font):
    • Teaching Philosophy and Practice [25 points]. Share your teaching
      philosophy by describing your understanding of how people learn, and how
      that understanding, in turn, informs what you value most as an instructor
      and the way you approach teaching. This explanation could include your
      fundamental understanding of the purpose of education, the nature of
      learning, and/or your role as a teacher in facilitating that learning. Please
      describe the instructional strategies and evidence-based practices that you
      utilize to support your teaching philosophy.
    • Course Design [25 points]. Connecting course design to your teaching
      philosophy and practices, describe how you have approached instructional
      design in one of your courses. Focus on the main elements of instructional
      design (e.g. objectives, course organization, content and format, learning
      activities, interaction, assessments) and provide examples from your course
      along with your rationale for adopting them.
    • Video clip of “Teaching in Action” (10-minute maximum/electronic link
      provided [25 points]
      Provide a link to a 10-minute video clip from a collegiate-level course that
      demonstrates your teaching in action along with a one-paragraph
      description explaining how this video is representative of your teaching
      philosophy and practices. A variety of teaching settings may be used for the
      video including but not limited to lecture, facilitated discussion, lab, etc. as
      appropriate to the course. The focus should be on activities that
      demonstrate exceptional or innovative instruction or student learning, such
      as student engagement, personalized learning, project-based learning, etc.
      For asynchronous online courses, a video presentation by the instructor of
      key engaged learning activities, or learning environments, would be an
      example of good evidence.

      Please note that instructors need to adhere to all campus FERPA policies,
      including those for sharing class lectures. If your campus does not have a
      policy in place, instructors should pass around a sheet where all present
      students give their permission, via signature, for the specific video(s) to be
      shared.

    • Evidence of Effective Student/Colleague Mentoring [10 points]. Describe
      your experience with mentoring students outside of the classroom, whether
      that be related to the courses you teach or in other settings. Additionally,
      discuss any experience you have with mentoring your peers or colleagues in
      the context of teaching.
    • Evidence of Professional Development [15 points]. Explain how you have
      used professional development opportunities to grow in your teaching
      excellence. If appropriate, how have you aligned professional development
      in the feedback you have received on your teaching?

PLEASE NOTE:
The entire application must be submitted as one single pdf – no exceptions. Title the
document with the nominee’s name and institution (e.g., JaneDoe_University Name).
Excluding the nomination form and letters of nomination and support, the nominee’s
Teaching Portfolio is limited to six (6) pages double spaced, in 12-point font with one-inch
margins. Applications which do not adhere to submission requirements, including
deadlines, page limits, formatting, and video length, will not be considered.